Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bullshit & Biases's avatar

Now if only the LLMs could keep up and do dialectical materialism like a human can, or at least some of them who weren't raised to believe in a figment of their imagination. It would be nice if an LLM understood real world constraints for a change, but rather than measure any real situation, it just fetches some bias from a political bin involving identity, like it's an answer to anything.

Getting LLMs understand environmental constraints in a garage is about one of the funniest examples of testing I've ever done. It skips the most basic of safety checks because it doesn't think real world context matters. It just assumes it already knows the perfect conditions exist. This stuff has to be laughably funny for most business owners. I gotta think this only works for a limited number of business types that can be profitable.

Non stop fundamental attribution error all day. It even blames my business partner for things he couldn't cause. Like it's trying to start a fight between us.

The narrative this will take everyone's job is hilarious, but what it shows is that engineers and AI companies live in an echo chamber. I doubt they talk to anyone who isn't a corporate stiff, the only world that exists is their own and the internet. The rest of us were forgotten about. We're just over here laughing at the attribution errors.

Harjaap's avatar

The 1900 factory comparison is the sharpest framing of this I've seen. The tell for me is that the 'floor plan' is usually undocumented: nobody can say who owns a decision or where an input comes from, so there's nothing for the AI to attach to. That's less a tooling gap than a structure gap, and it would explain why the 5% look like the teams that redrew the workflow first.

20 more comments...

Ready for more?